Facility profile New York
SLS Residential, Inc.
SLS Residential, Inc. was a program in Brewster, New York. It closed in 2008.
About SLS Residential, Inc.
SLS Residential was a private residential mental health program for adolescents and young adults in Brewster, New York.source 1, source 2 For five years it fought New York's Office of Mental Health (OMH) in hearings and courts.source In November 2006 the state fined it $110,000 and ordered it to stop admitting patients.source In 2007 former patients filed a federal class action alleging illegal restraints and isolation.source In August 2010 OMH revoked its licenses, and in November 2011 an appeals court upheld the revocation.source
SLS ran two community residences and an outpatient clinic.source OMH inspectors surveyed all three on November 6, 2006.source On November 17 the agency ordered SLS to stop admitting patients and stop using a building called "the Barn," and fined it $80,000 for eight violations.source On November 28 it added $30,000 for two breaches of those orders.source The violations included limits on patients' visits and phone calls, drug tests that required staff to watch patients, punishments handed out through a group called ADP, and staff hired without fingerprinting.source OMH also charged that staff held patients in manual restraints.source Its chairmen were Joseph Santoro and Alfred Bergman, and it did business through affiliated companies including SLS Health, SLS Wellness and Supervised Lifestyles Inc., headquartered on Route 6 in Southeast.source According to its website, as quoted in 2007, it charged as much as $950 a day.source
Also in 2007, two former patients, Nicholas J. Romano and Deborah A. Morgan, filed a federal class action on behalf of everyone SLS had treated.source They alleged illegal manual restraints, isolation rooms, nightly body and room searches, and denial of patients' rights to refuse treatment, to leave and to call their families.source They also claimed SLS discriminated against them under the Americans with Disabilities Act.source They sought $75 million in compensatory and $150 million in punitive damages.source Besides the companies and their chairmen, the suit named the employees Rob Giordano, Matt Sena and Gabe Caputo and the therapists Shawn Prichard and Robert Deletis.source 1, source 2 The complaint alleged that SLS employees, "including but not limited to Sena and Caputo," grabbed and shoved patients, threw them to the ground, pinned them to the floor and sat on them, with the knowledge and approval of Santoro, Prichard, Bergman and Deletis.source In July 2008 the judge, Stephen Robinson, apologized to an SLS lawyer he had criticized over the lobbying of former patients to opt out of the suit.source He then found that SLS therapists had told about 80 former patients that their private medical records would be made public if they joined, some falsely saying the judge had ordered it.source Calling the conduct "astounding," he fined SLS $35,000, voided the opt-outs and held its top managers responsible.source SLS's chief clinical officer, Dr. Shawn Prichard, allegedly called the meeting where the plan was made.source
Meanwhile the state case moved against SLS.source 1, source 2 In April 2008 a hearing officer upheld the 2006 findings, and that July OMH's commissioner adopted the fines.source 1, source 2 On August 29, 2008, OMH moved to revoke SLS's operating certificates.source It charged that SLS kept using illegal restraints, kept violating patients' rights and lacked "the character and competence" to run a licensed program.source OMH also accused it of sedating patients who refused medication and of failing to report suicidal behavior and abuse complaints.source That same year the Commission on Accreditation of Rehabilitation Facilities (CARF) re-accredited SLS for three years.source
SLS took both actions to court.source In September 2008 co-owner Joseph Santoro said SLS had not had a fair hearing, and the company sued in state Supreme Court.source That December a Putnam County judge annulled the fines.source 1, source 2 In November 2009 the Appellate Division reinstated $100,000 of them.source It struck only the $10,000 restraint fine, because OMH had never formally adopted its rule treating manual holds as restraints.source On August 9, 2010, OMH's commissioner revoked the certificates for both residences and the clinic.source The hearing officer had dismissed the restraint charges for the same reason but sustained every other charge.source On November 15, 2011, the Appellate Division confirmed the revocation and dismissed SLS's challenge on the merits.source In 2014 the court refused a request by outside parties to unseal the record of the fines case.source
Timeline
From the records: who ran it and the deals that moved it, its names, and the deaths, incidents, inspection findings, lawsuits and news stories on file. Point at an event, or tap "More about this", for the details.
2006
Restraint
OMH found patients were restrained against their will in violation of state law, including in a room not under video surveillance.
Restraint
source
License action
The state Office of Mental Health fined SLS $110,000 for eight violations found on Nov.
License action November 2006
The state Office of Mental Health fined SLS $110,000 for eight violations found on Nov. 17, 2006 and three more on Nov. 28, 2006, including illegal restraints and no criminal background checks.
source
License action
The state fined SLS Residential Inc.
License action December 7, 2006
The state fined SLS Residential Inc. (Brewster, NY) for eight violations, per the Journal News.
source
2007
Abuse
A complaint alleged SLS employees Sena and Caputo assaulted patients by shoving, throwing them to the ground and pinning them.
Abuse
source
Lawsuit
A 2007 class-action lawsuit alleged SLS violated patients' rights under the Americans With Disabilities Act and seeks $75 million compensatory and $150 million punitive damages.
Lawsuit
source
2008
License action
A hearing officer found SLS violated patients' rights and broke the law; the OMH Commissioner upheld the findings in June 2008.
License action
source
License action
New York State Office of Mental Health upheld $100,000 in fines against SLS Residential, Inc.
License action July 5, 2008
New York State Office of Mental Health upheld $100,000 in fines against SLS Residential, Inc. over violations found by state inspectors.
Lawsuit
A U.S. District Judge apologized for criticizing an SLS Residential attorney during the SLS class-action lawsuit over lobbying former patients to opt out of a...
Lawsuit July 18, 2008
A U.S. District Judge apologized for criticizing an SLS Residential attorney during the SLS class-action lawsuit over lobbying former patients to opt out of a multimillion dollar suit against the company.
License action
New York OMH revoked SLS Residential Inc.'s operating permits in late August 2008 after fining it $110,000 in November 2006 for 11 violations; SLS sued to stay open.
License action August 2008
New York OMH revoked SLS Residential Inc.'s operating permits in late August 2008 after fining it $110,000 in November 2006 for 11 violations; SLS sued to stay open. Allegations included illegal restraints and sedating patients who refused medication.
Lawsuit
SLS Residential, Inc.
Lawsuit September 15, 2008
SLS Residential, Inc. filed suit in state Supreme Court to reverse a ruling that put its state operating licenses in jeopardy.
Lawsuit
In the federal class action against SLS Residential, a federal judge fined SLS $35,000 for trying to scare former patients away from participating in the lawsuit (October 2008).
Lawsuit October 2008
License action
The state Office of Mental Health revoked the operating licenses over illegal restraints and misleading testimony after a $110,000 fine in 2006; SLS sued to stay open.
License action October 2008
License action
A state Supreme Court judge ruled in favor of SLS Residential, Inc., stopping state action against it and cancelling $110,000 in fines.
License action December 8, 2008
Closed
2011
Court record - SLS Residential, Inc.
Court record - SLS Residential, Inc.
SLS Residential, Inc., which operated mental health residential facilities and a clinic, challenged a determination by the New York State Office of Mental Health to revoke its operating certificates due to charges including lack of character and competence and violation of patient rights.
Outcome: Determination confirmed, petition denied, and proceeding dismissed on the merits.
- Court
- Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York, Second Department
- Status
- Unknown
Lawsuits
-
Court record - SLS Residential, Inc.
Outcome: Determination confirmed, petition denied, and proceeding dismissed on the merits.
SLS Residential, Inc., which operated mental health residential facilities and a clinic, challenged a determination by the New York State Office of Mental Health to revoke its operating certificates due to charges including lack of character and competence and violation of patient rights. The Appellate Division found that the determination was supported by substantial evidence and rejected claims of procedural untimeliness and hearing officer bias. The court confirmed the administrative determination, denied the petition, and dismissed the proceeding.
Staff
Administration
-
Alfred Bergman
Former Chairmansource
-
Joseph Santoro
Former Co-owner and Chief Operating Officer, Chairman (2008-2015)source
Notable staff
Rules and practices
Practices
- Restraint
- Seclusion or isolation
- Forced medication
- Behavior contracts
Documents
From the Unsilenced archive
1 document about SLS Residential, Inc. that Unsilenced collected and Kids Over Profits does not hold a copy of. They open on Unsilenced's Google Drive. Their whole folder: SLS Residential.
We have questions about SLS Residential, Inc.
If you were there, worked there or sent your child there, you can help fill in what our records are missing. Each question takes a moment; skip anything you do not know.
